This is Starting to Sound Elizabethan

Fr. James Melnick - Elizabethan


Msgr. Robert Hugh Benson wrote a novel Come Rack! Come Rope! about religious persecution during the Elizabethan era in England. This more-than-just-a-novel shows the gradualness of the bullying of Catholics into submission and execution by the British government. And its story is very apropos for the United States today.

Robin and Marjorie are two lovers who at the beginning of the book find out that the girl\’s father had been taxed one time too many for being Catholic. In England at the time, the monarchy levied a tax or a penalty for not worshiping in the Church of England.

As the plot unfolds, Robin and Marjorie become enamored with a higher love, with the One who is Love. Robin decides to become a Catholic priest, and Marjorie dedicates her life to preserving the Catholic faith in her locale of Derbyshire, England, by coordinating clandestine Masses and hiding priests. She abandons her father, who becomes progressively protestant and involved with the government and its obsession to stomp out the Catholic faith. Catholics are soon put in jail for not paying the fines, and later condemned to be hung at Tyburn Tree for not cooperating with the government and its religion. Robin does a fine job living out his Catholic faith without capitulating. The final scenes are tragic, and best left to be read yourself. Joseph Pearce back in February wrote a great article for Crisis Magazine on this book.

Of course, religion was never the cited reason for the persecution. It was dressed up as a civic fault. Treason. Taxed. Given citations and fined. Imprisoned. Silenced. Killed. For justice\’s sake. It was just the right thing to do for the kingdom.

These days in America, 237 years after the first protest for freedom, are we on the brink of these turbulent times? Fines? Imprisonments? I imagine that taxing and fining are the first ways any organization or institution tries to sway anyone from protesting. Money is definitely a talking point. But I imagine many Catholics and bishops will not stop fighting for religious freedom based on this. If we do not comply by the August 1st deadline to have our schools and hospitals in line with the ACA policies, we will be fined I imagine. And then what? When all our money is gone? Will they confiscate our schools and hospitals? Our parish halls? What then? Imprisoning the bishops until they repent? I have not seen the penalties yet for non-compliance, but it surely sounds Elizabethan. And there will be the choice. Do we just cave in, like Marjorie\’s father? It doesn\’t seem so bad to buy insurance, right? The overall good will outweigh an abortion or two. God will forgive our weakness. Or do we stand up like Robin to the bitter end? Martyrs in those days were willing to die for smaller matters of conscience.

At what point would I start suffering for my faith?

Our God is a God of Strength and Fortitude. And I am weak. I\’m not the stuff of which martyrs are made. May God help me and all Catholics persevere if we are threatened to relax our faith in order to please the government. As for now, we pray during this Fortnight for Freedom that the laws and those who make them would respect religious freedom, that we would avoid 16th-century injustice and brutality (although perhaps the 20th century saw more martyrs than even those terrible times). I pray for the president, the elected officials, and for the bishops that we may be dedicated to true freedom and persevere in justice.

© 2013. Fr. James Melnick. All Rights Reserved.

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest

7 thoughts on “This is Starting to Sound Elizabethan”

  1. The familiar phrase: “go to church” as id “Did you go to church?” was asked to see if you had gone to the Sunday Holy Eucharist (or Morning Prayer) service at the local Church of England building.

  2. Thank you Fr. Melnick for a great article. You are doing what we all should be doing. Getting ourselves and each other ready for the coming persecution. I wish more priests would focus on this issue and help us build strength. Thankfully our pastor is just such a man.

    One question, do you know why more priests don’t speak out and give us the hard facts as well as the good. Up until I joined my new parish, I hadn’t heard a priest speak boldly about sin, hell, government persecution, etc. I am not trying to speak abusively of them, I just want to understand so I don’t feel so let down. If it wasn’t for priests like you, I would feel like I am fighting a battle for the Catholic faith as a minority among Catholics.

  3. I have long had a fascination and love for the English martyrs under Henry and Elizabeth and more. I have read Msgr. Benson’s book. His “Lord of the World” is quite interesting as well.
    And I have read St. Thomas More’s “Comfort in the Midst of Tribulation” as he prepared for martyrdom. We do not like in 1955 wearing our Sunday best to Mass every week and to regular confession, etc. In those days if the Church did not approve of a book of movie, it flopped. Now our leaders have lost their moral authority for the most part and the CAtholics left in the pews are dumbed down after decades of non-catechesis. It is for the few to stand strong for the sake of the souls of the others.

  4. Pingback: Living Gargoyles The Medieval Art of Gurning -

  5. Pingback: This is Starting to Sound Elizabethan - CATHOLIC FEAST - Every day is a Celebration

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: