Hell: Real and Freely Chosen

frustration, anger, confusion, sadness, alone

frustration, anger, confusion, sadness, aloneAs we approach the end of this liturgical year, the Church reminds us to contemplate life after death. One doctrine clearly taught by Christ is hell – the state of eternal misery. Far too often today there is silence from the pulpit and in our catechesis regarding hell, possibly due to an assumption this reality is straightforward and exists. However, evidence suggests this is a false presumption, so it is beneficial for us to be reminded that not only is hell real and frightening, it is a possibility for any one of us depending on choices we freely make in life.

The Devil’s Deceptions

Among the many clever tricks of the devil, three stand out related to hell. Firstly, he tries to convince people hell does not exist. Then, in his cunning, he attempts to fool those who accept the reality of hell into thinking there is no chance they could ever go there after death. A third form of attack by the devil is to influence people to become indifferent to sin and to disregard the explicit warnings of Scripture related to eternal consequences of our choices.

If inclined to think the devil’s ploys are futile, you are wrong. Several groups who call themselves “Christians” reject either the reality of hell or at least the eternal aspect of damnation (Mormons, Seventh-Day Adventists, Jehovah’s Witnesses and Christadelphians are a few examples). Additionally, Americans, regardless of religious affiliation, have fallen prey to this deception with one recent poll in 2013 showing only 53% believed in hell. Furthermore, in this same poll, 62% of Americans believed heaven was real and that is where they would be after death. We can also observe Western culture to see signs of Satan’s successes with many people – including Christians – carelessly living contrary to God’s teachings and basing decisions on worldly standards, emotions, and passions rather than using theocentric standards.

To counter this duplicity of the devil, God has given us admonitions throughout Scripture so we can avoid being deceived. God’s Word reveals hell is a state of eternal suffering and separation from God. Hell is the result of rejecting God through grave sin.

The Reality of Hell

The idea of a state of eternal suffering is frightening, as it should be. When Scripture refers to hell, terrifying descriptions are given, such as “place of torment” (Luke 16:28), “unquenchable fire” (Matthew 3:12), “outer darkness” (Matthew 8:12) and “eternal destruction” (2 Thessalonians 1:9). Jesus uses the appalling depiction of hell as a state “where their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched” (Mark 9:48). Imagining these horrors of hell, I have been asked how a loving God could create such an existence.

Hell is not the result of God’s positive act of creation. It is the result of people freely rejecting God and His love. Satan and the demons freely separated themselves from God in the beginning, and, since then, many people have chosen to join the fallen outside the Beatific Vision.

God desires all men to be with Him in heaven (1 Timothy 2:4), but, because God is the perfect gentlemen, He respects our choices and will never coerce us to act against our will. Therefore when we stand before the judgment seat of Christ, we will face two scenarios. Christ will bestow on some entrance into a state of everlasting happiness to be in the presence of God in heaven. This reward will be for those died with God’s gift of grace within their soul and will have had faith and been obedient to God in life. However, there will also be those who die and come before Christ without God’s grace either because they rejected His love, refused to have faith or who were unrepentant. In this scenario, Christ will grant to these people a continuation of the life they chose to live – spiritual separation from God. This latter state is not the result of God’s desires but is the consequence of man’s earthly choices. (See the Catechism of the Catholic Church 1021-1022; 1033-1041)

The Pains of Hell

Scripture provides some limited descriptions of hell (Jeremiah 23:39-40; Revelation 14:11; 20:10), and the Church Fathers also give us their speculations, allowing us to begin to have a hint of the wretchedness. An existence in hell is one of suffering, misery, sorrow and hatred; the degree of torment is inconceivable in our minds. The Fathers surmise those in hell will ultimately experience two types of pain: the pain of the senses and the pain of the loss of God.

Men in hell are surrounded by darkness, unable to see clearly, enveloped by an offensive stench emitted from all the citizens of hell. There is constant physical suffering from the pains of fire which burns without consuming as well as the agony of an intense hunger and thirst that can never be quenched. They are bombarded with the sounds of howls, woeful lamentations, and vulgarity. Beyond these horrors, a most intense positive pain is experienced because of the complete spiritual separation from God Himself. Outweighing every other torment, those in hell are acutely aware God is the ultimate source of man’s highest felicity yet they have chosen their fate. They are now cognizant of the many graces God had offered them throughout their lives which they rejected, and they fully understand their state is not the result of a vengeful God but due to their own choices. They are filled with remorse and shame. A desire for eternal bliss will be ever-present but will be unfulfilled, leading to despair.

Hell Is Only For Murderers, Right?

Someone once made the comment, “Why are some afraid of hell? Not many will be there and it is really only a place for people who have committed serious sins like murder or who have apostatized from faith in Christ.” There are two major errors in this statement.

Hell does not have a small population. In addition to the large population of demons, Jesus Himself warns us “many” human beings will be there:

Enter by the narrow gate; for the gate is wide and the way is easy, that leads to destruction, and those who enter by it are many. For the gate is narrow and the way is hard, that leads to life, and those who find it are few.  Matthew 7:13-14

This revelation is contrary to any idea hell is sparsely populated, plus, Jesus informs us the path leading to eternal damnation is easy, and as such, a tempting one to tread down.

Furthermore, Jesus teaches it is not only unbelievers who are in hell but also those who believe in Christ yet who are disobedient to God:

Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. On that day many will say to me, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’ And then I will declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from me, you evildoers’ .  Mt 7:21-23

Jesus is in no way ambiguous. It is not only what and in whom we believe but how we live our lives. Sin is disobedience, and committing a grave sin is choosing to turn away from God. We may appear to be virtuous or able to do great works in the name of Jesus, but God knows every aspect of our heart so there is nothing we can hide from Him. If we are living in sin, we are far from God, which is why Jesus urgently calls all to repentance before it is too late. Throughout the Gospels Jesus instructs us how we must live to enter heaven, including loving God and neighbor and keeping the commandments (Matthew 19:16-22). St. Paul also explicitly tells us a few of the grave sins which could result in eternal damnation (1 Corinthians 6:9-11). Using these cautionary words, God could not be any clearer in His warnings.

Fear of Hell to Lead to Repentance

Awareness of the reality of hell and the agony suffered should be alarming. But consolation comes in recognizing God who wants us to be with Him in heaven and offers us His grace to assist us. Additionally, God has revealed not only the way to heaven but the truths of the danger of choosing hell by how we live. The Church reminds us, this fear of hell is a gift. As the Catechism of the Catholic Church discusses, though repentance motivated by the dread of punishment is not perfect contrition, it can still stir one’s conscience and initiate the process of conversion along with the promptings of grace (1453). Then, if we are receptive to the transforming power of grace, this communion with God, initially motivated by terror, can be metamorphosed into a desire for union with God propelled by love.

Our Response: Despair Or Conversion?

These truths about hell should create uneasiness within our hearts, but we must also caution against despair, irrational fear and anxiety. Hell is a fate freely chosen. These teachings of Christ and His Church are calls for conversion since we know neither the day nor the hour when we will be standing before the judgment seat of Christ.

For non-Christians who do not know God, there is an obligation to obey the natural law God has placed in our hearts and to sincerely seek Him (Romans 2:6-16). Faithful Christians should strive to avoid sin and repent when we fall. We must also recognize Divine Revelation is undeniable: the consequence of sin is choosing to be spiritually separated from God and, if we die in this state, this separation from God will be eternal.

The desire to avoid sin may seem impossible on our own but with God, nothing is impossible (Mark 10:25-27). God offers all of us His grace. This supernatural power enables us to have faith and be obedient to God, as well as giving us the ability to resist temptation. But even with grace, we must always be cautious to not become presumptuous. We cannot say “because God is merciful He will not condemn me if I persist in my sins.” Rather, God exhorts us to not delay in turning away from our sins to repentance (Peter 1:3-23). 

Hell is Real and Freely Chosen

Hell is real, and this eternal experience of misery is a consequence of sin chosen in this life. God has revealed truths of hell so we will not fall prey to the lies of the devil. God is giving us the time to turn away from our sins. Now is the time of grace, repentance, conversion and mercy. After death, the time of justice will have come and judgment by Christ Himself will be based not only on faith but on all earthly deeds – “for we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each one may receive good or evil, according to what he has done in the body” [in his earthly life] (2 Corinthians 5:10). Hell is not merely for apostates and murderers; the citizens of hell will include some of the baptized, even priests and bishops. Jesus warns us of the consequences of our actions and calls us daily to conversion.

Knowing we all will ultimately spend eternity in either heaven or hell, it is critical we acknowledge the drastic differences between these two states. And though disturbing, we cannot neglect to contemplate the realities of hell to remind ourselves of the grave consequences of sin. As Dr. Peter Kreeft wrote:

If all of life’s roads lead to the same place, it makes no ultimate difference what choice we make. But if they lead to opposite places, to infinite bliss or infinite misery, unimaginable glory or unimaginable tragedy…then life is a life or death affair…and our choice of roads is infinitely important (Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Heaven).


Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest

8 thoughts on “Hell: Real and Freely Chosen”

  1. Franklin P. Uroda

    One of the divine attributes of The Deity-Father, Jesus, Holy Spirit-is omnipresence, being everywhere, all the time. Does the devil have this attribute as well? Or does everyone have a personal devil that’s always seeking the spiritual destruction of the person to whom its assigned? I can’t find much in the CCC. If there are personal fallen angels, billions upon billions of them must have said “Non serviam”.

  2. Pingback: Contemplating Heaven - Our Ultimate Goal - Catholic Stand : Catholic Stand

  3. This is something that needs to be read by all… It is so easy to fall into rationalizations and excuses for our bad behavior–even that is an euphemism for sins–in society today. Bad is good and good is bad. Not so says God through Scripture and His Holy Catholic Church. We can only choose to love and serve God, He doesn’t make us. Therefore the converse is true–We can only choose to hate and ignore God, but He doesn’t make us. Confession is the balm of the soul that keeps us walking to that narrow gate.

  4. I think the many references and graphic descriptions you’ve compiled could be made into an Oscar winning movie rated C for condemned. If you could get Stephen King to rewrite some of the script, Steve Spielberg to direct and my favorite, LionsGate studios for special effects there’s no doubt this little horror film could be used by the EWTN to draw in those ‘many not chosen’ for at least a peek at what is to come. Since there are so many villains, Borgia pope types and even ordinary cafeteria Catholics, casting would be a piece of cake. In the final scene we could have Aquinas looking down into the pit as he ascertained was part of the show and with a sad smile turn back to his heavenly mansion with a shrug. Happy Advent to you too.

  5. AAquinas- God so loved each of use, making us in His image, that He made us absolutely free; and thus when we say Not Thy WIll But Mine Be Done, God does not use His power to forcibly change us and He indeed does allow us to choose hell over heaven with Him. Depending on your definition of “sociopathy”, the case can be made that these folks do not act freely. Allison T L-thank you for making this so clear (using some of that massive amount of free time you enjoy) – and, despite some recent errors from hierarchical places – for making it clear that there is a hell and we can choose to go there for all eternity. Guy McClung, San Antonio, Texas.

  6. So, you feel that “hell” is freely chosen…that people freely chose a place of eternal damnation? Well, a sociopath who robs, manipulates and kills can change his behavior? Any scientific, peer reviewed research? The DSM speaks to personality disorders which are not amenable to therapy, does it not? Should we drug sociopaths into a stupor where they cannot act and avoid hell or should we manipulate the genes of personality disordered souls. Some people can not freely chose anything …genetics and nurture create a path and god will not condemn these souls to eternal fire. You cannot free a soul from sociopathy like You cannot free a body from an inoperable blastoglioma. As Satre said in No Exist….”Hell is ust other people.”

    1. Allison Tobola Low

      Thank you for your comments. I would argue that the majority of people do not fall into the categories you mention. (It is true many do suffer with psychological disorders BUT fortunately most are not so severe as to lead to the radical/immoral behavior you describe.)
      But if we take the situations you gave, the question in those cases is in regards to whether the act is truly “freely chosen”. If you read the Catechism of the Catholic Church particularly #1857-1861, the Church recognizes your situations. The Church teaches that with grave sin, it is possible the moral responsibility can be diminished if one is coerced to do something by external pressures or pathological disorders. If someone has no awareness of the gravity of an act or has no possible way to control their behavior, God recognizes this knowing us better than we know ourselves, and this is considered at our judgment. It is not for me to judge one’s eternal fate in a given circumstance – that is for God alone, and God is perfectly merciful as well as perfectly just.
      But the emphasis of this article is that we all need to be aware of the gravity of sin and the reality of hell.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sign Up for the Catholic Stand Newsletter!

%d bloggers like this: